Saturday, November 7, 2026
Safety

UK CAA explores the ‘risk of not using drones’

When assessing professional drone operations, the focus is usually on the risks created by flying the drone. But what if the question were turned around? What risks arise when a drone is not used? The UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) is currently exploring this question as part of its UAS Advisory Committee. The initiative looks at the concept of ‘risk transfer’: comparing the risks associated with a drone operation with those associated with the traditional method that the drone replaces.

What is the risk of not using a drone?

The principle is relatively straightforward. A drone can introduce risks of its own. It can crash, collide with another aircraft or cause damage to people or property. These are the risks that are normally at the centre of an aviation safety assessment.

At the same time, however, a drone can remove or significantly reduce other risks. Consider the inspection of a tall structure. Without a drone, someone may have to work at height, using scaffolding or a cherry picker. An inspection over water could require personnel to work from a boat or in difficult-to-access locations.

A drone can reduce or eliminate some of these risks by keeping people on the ground. It is even conceivable that drones could replace helicopters for certain applications, for example during search and rescue missions.

The question is therefore not simply how much risk a drone introduces, but also how much risk its use removes.

CAA asks industry for evidence

UK drone industry association ARPAS-UK says the subject is currently being explored within the CAA UAS Advisory Committee. The aim is to better understand situations in which drones can reduce or transfer risk compared with conventional methods.

The organisation is now asking drone operators and other professionals to provide concrete examples. General statements that an activity is ‘safer with a drone’ are not considered sufficient. The CAA is looking for figures, statistics, real-world examples and other evidence that can help quantify the effect.

The initiative covers a broad range of sectors, including inspection and surveying, agriculture, transport, infrastructure and utilities. Examples could include replacing a helicopter inspection with a drone operation, or avoiding the need for workers to operate at height.

The deadline for submissions is 30 September.

A different perspective on drone safety

The UK initiative is interesting because it adds another perspective to the conventional approach to drone safety. Under the European regulatory framework, an operational risk assessment such as SORA primarily looks at the risks associated with the proposed UAS operation. This includes ground risk and air risk, as well as the mitigations required to reduce those risks.

The risks associated with the activity that the drone replaces are not the primary subject of that assessment. From an aviation safety perspective, this is understandable: a drone operation needs to be safe regardless of which alternative method would otherwise have been used.

For professional applications, however, the wider context can be highly relevant. A drone may introduce a new aviation risk while simultaneously reducing an existing occupational or operational risk.

A Dutch example: the ‘drone label’

There is already an interesting example of this broader approach in the Netherlands. Rijkswaterstaat, the Dutch government agency responsible for the country’s main infrastructure, previously experimented with a so-called ‘drone label’ for infrastructure inspections.

The approach compared drone-based inspections with traditional inspection methods, taking into account not only costs but also the safety of inspectors, traffic disruption and CO₂ emissions. Traditional inspections may involve working at height, the use of boats, cherry pickers or traffic management measures. A drone can potentially reduce or eliminate some of those requirements.

The Dutch example is not identical to the ‘risk of not using drones’ approach being explored by the UK CAA, but the underlying principle is similar: rather than looking exclusively at the drone operation, consider what the alternative method would involve as well.

An interesting question for Europe

This approach could also be relevant to the way professional drone operations are assessed elsewhere in Europe. It would be interesting for example to look more systematically at the risks that are avoided when drones replace potentially hazardous conventional methods.

That does not mean that an occupational safety risk can simply be offset against an aviation safety risk. These are different risk domains, and determining how they should be compared raises difficult questions about responsibilities and regulatory mandates.

Nevertheless, the British initiative could provide an interesting starting point for EASA, national aviation authorities, and policymakers. The existing aviation safety assessment does not necessarily have to be abandoned. Instead, it could potentially be complemented by a more systematic assessment of the risks that a drone operation prevents.

The central question would then be not only ‘How safe is this drone operation?’, but also: ‘What risks are we accepting by not using the drone?’

Wiebe de Jager

Wiebe de Jager is the founder of Dronewatch (available in Dutch and English). Wiebe is an experienced drone pilot (EASA Specific category certified) and has published a number of bestselling books about drone photography and cinematography.

Leave a Reply

Sign up for our Newsletter